STIMPACK Systems Architecture Lab • Stock-Flow Consistent Diagnostic Engine
Schema 3.0-worldcoder-interactive•Live Intelligence Wire →

Haiti’s Fiscal, Security & Economic Metabolism: Interactive Systems Explorer

Single-variable narratives—“just end corruption,” “just send strike forces,” “just hold snap elections,” or “just restore humanitarian grants”—repeatedly fail in Haiti because they violate hard stock-flow accounting ceilings and coupled threshold gates. Every node, pipe, feedback circuit, and equation below is directly inspectable down to primary Haitian Treasury (MEF), Central Bank (BRH), World Bank, IMF, enacted U.S. statute, and PostGIS street-sensor records.

1. Dollar Price Accounting Basis (3.03x CPI/FX Wedge)
2. Population Denominator (5.69% Sensitivity)
Why both toggles exist: Cumulative 17%–37% CPI inflation against a remittance-pinned 130.74 gourde makes nominal GDP look 3.03x larger ($39.39B) than real output ($13.00B), while IMF vs. WB population estimates shift per-citizen figures by 5.7%.
Trace Closed Causal Feedback Circuits (Click a Loop to Illuminate Its Path on the Graph):
COL 1 • EXTERNAL BOUNDARY POOLSCOL 2 • ENDOGENOUS GENERATOR (ECONOMY)COL 3 • 1-TO-4 FISCAL VALVE (MEF TOFE)COL 4 • 4 CONSUMING STREAMS & GANG STOCKEXTERNAL BOUNDARY POOLM 3.0/4Diaspora & HOPE/HELP Trade Pool
$5.62B/yr external private & export inflows
Haiti sits 700 miles from Miami on a ~$145B-GDP island with duty-free U.S. apparel access enacted through December 31, 2028 (H.R. 6500 / P.L. 119-103, approved Sept 2, 2026) and ~$5.10B/yr in diaspora remittances. Geography is NOT Haiti's binding constraint.
EXTERNAL AID / FORCE / ARMSM 2.0/4External Aid, Troops & Illicit Munitions
0.35x Self-Reliance/Relief Ratio [0.14x–0.81x] • ~4,300 foreign troops
Post-2025/2026 USAID contraction (~78% sector cut) shrank legacy NGO maintenance grants while external kinetic support bifurcated between UN-authorized GSF (~2,000 troops scaling toward 5,500) and ~2,300 bilateral Salvadoran forces operating outside UN detention rules—alongside illicit Florida/DR ammunition leakage into gangs.
SOLE ENDOGENOUS GENERATORM 1.1/4Productive Domestic Economy (Generator)
$13.00B Real (2015 $) GDP • -1.7% (8th yr down) • ~72% informal
In STIMPACK's 5-Work-Stream architecture, ONLY the Economy generates endogenous domestic surplus; the other 4 streams (Rule of Law, Governance, Social/Health, Ecology) consume fiscal revenue to protect and enable it. Eight consecutive years of real contraction (-17.5% since 2018) compressed real output to $13.00B while >70% informality caps taxable payrolls.
CASH & MICROCREDIT RAILSM 1.4/4Domestic Cash Rails & Microcredit
420 / 540 cash branches active (120 dark) • $4,358M usable remit
Roughly 120 of 540 physical transfer/bank payout branches closed under highway blockades, stranding digital remittances on bank ledgers while regional towns suffer physical gourde droughts. Conversely, Fonkoze scaling from 8 to 42 microfinance branches proves high repayment and credit appetite among Madan Sara women traders.
ENERGY & WATERSHED SUBSTRATEM 0.7/4Payment-Assured Power & Watersheds
$0.35–$0.50/kWh private diesel (25–40% firm opex) • ~2–4% primary forest
Public EDH grid collapse and arrears forced factories, hospitals, and telecoms onto high-cost private diesel generators while charcoal survival demand stripped ~95–98% of primary forest cover, turning mountain rains into topsoil-destroying flash floods.
1-TO-4 SOVEREIGN FISCAL VALVEM 0.8/4Sovereign Treasury & BRH Deficit Valve
$45.1/cap (WB pop) | $42.7/cap (IMF pop) Real 2015 $ • 3.2% of DR
Closed FY2025–26 MEF TOFE proves why 'just stop corruption' fails as a standalone cure: total tax & customs mobilized HTG 215.24B ($1,646.3M = 4.18% of GDP, with only 10.08% collected across all 9 provinces). Current operating payrolls & expenses consume 94.3% of tax revenue, and plugging the -HTG 57.53B cash deficit forced +HTG 52.15B (~$399M) in BRH central-bank money printing—re-fueling gourde inflation.
PER-CITIZEN FISCAL CEILING (REAL 2015 $)Haiti Actual (4.18% GDP)$42.7 (2.8%)0% Graft @ DR 14.7% Rate$150.2 (10.0%)Dominican Rep. (14.7%)$1498.9 (100.0%)+HTG 52.15B (~$399M) BRH Money PrintingAll 9 provinces = 10.1% of internal tax • Click to audit
RULE OF LAW • PHASE GATEM 0.6/4Cardinal Corridors & Node Control
Corridor Index 0.226 (0/19 fully open) • 22 event clusters/14d
Non-linear phase gate between Level-0 collapse and Level-1 recovery: reopening and HOLDING the 4 cardinal gateways (RN-1 North, RN-2 South, RN-8 Malpasse/$648M DR freight, RN-3 Centre) plus secondary bypass trails. Joint Haitian + Salvadoran/GSF operations seized a downtown wedge (Sylvio Cator, EDH HQ, Portail Léogâne) and struck Tibwadòm/RN-8, but holding requires bypass overwatch and immediate utility/merchant backfill.
RULE OF LAW • DETENTION VALVEM 0.5/4Detention & Pre-Trial Court Valve
0.15 Detention Intake Valve • 80–85% untried • CERMICOL 735 in 93 beds (790%)
After mass prison breaks, surviving facilities run at 3x–8x capacity (CERMICOL juvenile/annex holds 735 detainees in 93 beds; ~80–85% are unconvicted pre-trial detainees, many past statutory max sentences). Because UN GSF rules cap custody at 48–72 hours before Haitian transfer, zero bed intake forces raids into lethal-only dispersal rather than arrests that yield defections and command-chain intelligence.
GOVERNANCE • 10.1% PROVINCIALM 0.5/4Legitimacy & Municipal Fiscal Share
10.08% Provincial Tax Share • 0 elected officials • 746k ONI ID backlog
Zero elected officials hold office nationwide; post-TPC executive decree rule pushed elections to July 18, 2027 while concentrating 89.9% of domestic tax collection and nearly all discretionary 'comptes courants' (HTG 16.3B) in Port-au-Prince—turning central executive capture into a high-stakes zero-sum prize.
SOCIAL • KONBIT BUFFERM 1.0/4Subsistence Pressure & Konbit Buffer
5.9M IPC3+ food-insecure • 1.5M IDPs (>90% hosted by cousins / 93% provincial schools)
Roughly half the population (~5.9M, including ~1.8–2.0M IPC-4 emergency) faces acute food insecurity, while >90% of Haiti's ~1.5M displaced citizens bypassed tent camps into provincial relatives' homes and 93% of surveyed fee-dependent non-public schools—an extraordinary unbudgeted 'konbit' shock absorber now nearing exhaustion.
ADVERSARIAL PREDATION STOCKM 0.7/4Armed Gang Coalitions (Predation Stock)
9k–15k fighters • ZERO domestic bullet factories • $3–$7/rd street ammo
Viv Ansanm, 400 Mawozo, 5 Segond, Gran Grif, and Kokorat San Ras manufacture ZERO firearms or ammunition inside Haiti. Their coercive power is a flow-sustained stock fed by highway/port checkpoint tolls ($1,150–$2,000/container), smuggled Florida/DR ammunition ($3–$7/round), and youth scarcity recruitment.
$5.10B/yr$1.38B/yr$520M/yr-$4.4B imp$390M/yr$135M/yr$290M/yr$1.65B/yr+$399M BRH$320M/yr$230M/yr$90M tolls4.4k troops0.15 hold390k ppl/yr
Solid Pipes: Annualized USD Flows (width ∝ √USD; never summed with headcounts)Dashed Channels:Non-Monetary People, Troops & Detention Gates
Click any Stock, Pipe Tag, or Feedback Loopto inspect equations & primary sources
STOCK • governanceOFFICIAL PRIMARY LEDGER

Sovereign Fiscal Revenue Valve (MEF Closed FY2025–26 TOFE: 4.18% of GDP + BRH Monetization)

$45.1/cap (WB pop) | $42.7/cap (IMF pop) Real 2015 $ • 3.2% of DR
UNCERTAINTY BAND
[42.7 – 48.7]
USD_real_2015_per_capita_annual
STREAM MATURITY (0–4)
0.8 / 4.0 [0.5–1.1]
Slow Structural (Years)
Exact Derivation / Accounting Formula
Nominal_Tax = HTG 215,243M / 130.74 = $1,646.3M (4.18% of $39.389B GDP); Real_Tax/cap = ($13.0B × 4.18%) / Pop; Zero-Graft Ceiling @ DR 14.7% = $158.7/cap real (11.2% of DR $1,417)
Structural Role & Non-Linear Thresholds

Closed FY2025–26 MEF TOFE proves why 'just stop corruption' fails as a standalone cure: total tax & customs mobilized HTG 215.24B ($1,646.3M = 4.18% of GDP, with only 10.08% collected across all 9 provinces). Current operating payrolls & expenses consume 94.3% of tax revenue, and plugging the -HTG 57.53B cash deficit forced +HTG 52.15B (~$399M) in BRH central-bank money printing—re-fueling gourde inflation.

Hysteresis / Ceiling: Hard Stock-Flow Ceiling: even 0% graft and Dominican-grade 14.7% tax collection on today's $13.0B real economy yields at most ~$158.7/citizen real (~$455–$481 nominal)—still ~89% below the Dominican Republic's real fiscal capacity without multi-fold formal output growth.

Primary Sources & Verifiable Citations
  • MEF DEE Tableau des Opérations Financières de l'Etat Au 30 Septembre 2026 (Provisoire, published Nov 12, 2026)
  • World Bank GC.TAX.TOTL.GD.ZS (DOM 14.70% central-govt tax/GDP) & IMF WEO GGR_NGDP
Inspect Valve-Controller Dossiers on Haiti Monitor:
Judea Pearl Rung-2 Counterfactual Workbench•Accounting Basis: Real 2015 USD

Single-Lever Trope Stress-Tester & Coupled Threshold Simulator

Pull one lever in isolation to see the exact accounting identity or feedback gate that stops it—then pull coupled co-levers together to cross the Level-1 phase threshold.

1. Cardinal Corridor + Bypass Hold23% index
Baseline 0.23 (0/19 open) • Gate ≥ 0.50
2. Detention Valve + FL/DR Ammo Cut15% intake/choke
Baseline 0.15 (735/93 beds; 0 bullets made locally)
3. Customs Parity & Cash-Branch Openness38% parity
Baseline 38% (62% contraband; 120/540 dark branches)
4. Zero-Graft & Tax Admin Cleanliness32% clean
Bounded by Informality Share & Real GDP Base!
5. Escrow IPP Commercial Microgrids18% clusters
Replaces $0.42/kWh private factory diesel
6. 'Pickaxe' Self-Reliance : Relief Ratio0.35x ratio
Baseline 0.35x ($135M/$390M) • Target ≥ 1.5x–2.0x
Active Binding-Gate Diagnosis

BASELINE EQUILIBRIUM TRAP: 0.23 corridor openness, 0.15 detention intake, 62% customs evasion, and +$399M BRH deficit money-printing reinforce real output stagnation.

5-Yr Tax / Citizen (Real 2015 USD)
$44.4
Band [$36–$52] vs $42.7 now
3.0% of DR ($1499)
5-Yr Output (Real 2015 USD)
$12.36B
Formality: 24% • Tax/GDP: 4.8%
Level-1 Gate Openness: 2%
Hard Static 0%-Graft Ceiling [Tier 3]
$150.2 / citizen
Exact ceiling at DR 14.7% rate on today's fixed GDP (no growth)
Balloon Spillover & BRH Printing
7% Spillover Risk
BRH Monetization: ~$399M/yr (now $399M)
Epistemic Disclosure: REDUCED-FORM COUPLED STRUCTURAL SIMULATOR (5-Year Steady-State Horizon): Hard fiscal ceilings (e.g., zero-corruption revenue on fixed GDP) are exact accounting identities [TIER 3]. Multi-year output, formality, and security responses are parameterized non-linear structural equations [TIER 0 / MODELED] with explicit +/-18% uncertainty bands—designed to expose threshold gates and single-lever bottlenecks, NOT to issue point forecasts.

Following Hausmann, Rodrik & Velasco (Harvard Growth Lab), a constraint is genuinely binding—not merely one item on a 40-point laundry list—only when it simultaneously exhibits (1) an extreme Shadow Price, (2) immediate Shock Elasticity when relaxed, (3) expensive Bypass Workarounds by local actors, and (4) survival of constraint-light “Camels” alongside collapse of constraint-intensive “Hippos.”

RANK #1

Holding Cardinal Corridors + Secondary Bypass Trails (Level-0 → Level-1 Gate)

Fast Tactical (Days–Weeks)Severity 0.94
Test 1 • Shadow Price

$1,150–$2,000/container across ~7 RN-8 gang checkpoints; 0/19 monitored national corridors rated fully open (index 0.226).

Test 2 • Shock Elasticity

Whenever checkpoints clear briefly or barges dock, provincial wholesale prices and freight volumes respond within days.

Test 3 • Costly Bypasses

Private coastwise barges, helicopter charters for hospitals, armed night convoys, and farmers walking mountain trails (attacked at Morne-Robert to protect Liancourt toll monopolies).

Test 4 • Camels vs. Hippos

Weightless digital/microfinance & informal street vendors ('camels') survive; heavy road-dependent agro-processing and PaP apparel ('hippos') shrank ~50%.

SINGLE-LEVER WARNING: FALLACY: 'Headline point-seizures or killing gang leaders solves security.' Without mobile secondary-bypass overwatch, lawful detention cells (0.15 valve), and immediate commercial/power restart, gangs re-infiltrate cleared blocks or displace terror into rural Artibonite.
RANK #2

Compressed Real Output ($13.0B Real vs $39.4B Nominal, 3.03x FX Wedge) & 0.35x Capital Mix

Slow Structural (Years)Severity 0.91
Test 1 • Shadow Price

Closed FY25-26 MEF tax = $42.7–$45.1/citizen real (3.2% of DR); even 0% graft at DR 14.7% tax effort caps out at $158.7/citizen real (11.2% of DR).

Test 2 • Shock Elasticity

Fonkoze scaling 8→42 branches and Nord/CODEVI retaining ~27k formal jobs where corridors stay open prove rapid output response when barriers drop.

Test 3 • Costly Bypasses

72% informal self-employment, $5.10B family remittances substituting for missing wages, and 100k/yr skilled emigration.

Test 4 • Camels vs. Hippos

Import-resale traders ('camels' riding the remittance-pegged 130.74 gourde) outlast domestic rice farmers and formal manufacturers ('hippos' crushed by 3.03x real cost appreciation).

SINGLE-LEVER WARNING: FALLACY: 'If Haiti just ended corruption, everything else would follow.' An incorruptible president collecting Scandinavian-clean taxes on a $13.0B informal economy still lacks the revenue to police, educate, or power 12M+ citizens without multi-fold formal output growth.
RANK #3

Uninterdicted Florida/DR Ammunition Inflow & Saturated Pre-Trial Prisons (735 in 93 Beds)

Fast Tactical (Days–Weeks)Severity 0.87
Test 1 • Shadow Price

Street rifle ammo commands $3–$7/round (5x–12x U.S. retail); CERMICOL runs at 790% occupancy (80–85% untried) against GSF's 48–72h handover cap.

Test 2 • Shock Elasticity

Coast Guard / DR border ammo seizures immediately spike gang round prices and ration gang fire-fights.

Test 3 • Costly Bypasses

Security units defaulting to lethal-only raids (forgoing intelligence rollups) and bilateral Salvadoran units operating outside UN custody frameworks.

Test 4 • Camels vs. Hippos

Coastal/border-connected coalitions (5 Segond, 400 Mawozo) sustain fire intensity while isolated crews run dry.

SINGLE-LEVER WARNING: FALLACY: 'Wait years to build $100M prisons or debate UN mandate perfection.' Reopening the empty Pétion-Ville women's annex + mobile pre-trial clearance of over-served petty detainees + outbound Florida container X-rays unlock arrest capacity immediately.
RANK #4

62% Customs Evasion Penalty on Compliant Firms, +HTG 52.2B BRH Monetization & 120 Dark Cash Branches

Medium Corridor (Months)Severity 0.84
Test 1 • Shadow Price

AGD customs stalled at HTG 78.1B (-9% real YoY) forcing +HTG 52.2B BRH money printing; 6–8% wire fees cost ~$51M per percentage point.

Test 2 • Shock Elasticity

Prior customs manifest/border crackdowns produced immediate step-jumps in monthly AGD collections until bypass ports reopened.

Test 3 • Costly Bypasses

Informal coastal landing strips, contraband border trucks, physical cash couriers, and private USD hoarding.

Test 4 • Camels vs. Hippos

Untaxed contraband distributors undercut audited formal taxpayers who pay both legal tariffs and road tolls.

SINGLE-LEVER WARNING: FALLACY: 'Hike statutory tax rates on registered Port-au-Prince businesses.' Taxing the compliant 28% harder while 62% of border volume evades tariffs accelerates formal firm exit and forces more BRH deficit monetization.
RANK #5

Private Diesel Penalty ($0.35–$0.50/kWh) & 89.9% Capital-Centralized Fiscal Governance

Medium Corridor (Months)Severity 0.78
Test 1 • Shadow Price

25–40% of factory opex burned on private diesel; only 10.08% of internal taxes collected across all 9 provinces; 32.8% of annual capex dumped in September.

Test 2 • Shock Elasticity

Industrial parks with dedicated power (CODEVI/Caracol) retained ~90% of Haiti's surviving apparel exports.

Test 3 • Costly Bypasses

Every clinic, bank, and factory running redundant diesel gensets; households burning Last-Stand hillside trees for charcoal.

Test 4 • Camels vs. Hippos

Low-wattage trading survives; cold-chain agriculture and 24/7 manufacturing stall.

SINGLE-LEVER WARNING: FALLACY: 'Subsidize universal national EDH power or hold snap national elections before municipal delivery.' Ring-fenced commercial IPP microgrids and direct municipal infrastructure builds generate trust and solvency bottom-up.